💜 PAY OVER TIME WITH SEZZLE 💜

FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $149

FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $149. NOT VALID DURING SALES OR WITH OTHER DISCOUNTS

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Freshly Brewed Magick

New Arrivals

Plushies

130 Results

Clear filters
PBJ’s Plush Ball Jellies 💜 - Pugsy Malone - Stuffed Animals
PBJ’s Plush Ball Jellies 💜 - Stuffed Animals
33% off

PBJ's Plush Ball Jellies 💜

$14.99 $9.99 Sale

17 styles, 17 styles
  • Rainbow Unicorn
  • Fetch
  • Pugsy Malone
  • +14 more
  • Rainbow Unicorn
  • Fetch
  • Pugsy Malone
  • Cyclopz
  • Lily
  • Purrincess
  • Slowpoke
  • Triclopz
  • Spike
  • Mako
  • Delphine
  • Fish N. Chips
  • Fleecia
  • Chillie
  • Inky
  • Sizzley
  • Fowl Ball
Jellyroo Plush Animals Squish Tummy
Jellyroo Plush Animals Squish Tummy
22% off

Jellyroo Plush Animals Squish Tummy

$17.99 $13.99 Sale

15 styles, 15 styles
  • Tutu
  • Huckleberry
  • Sparkles
  • +12 more
  • Tutu
  • Huckleberry
  • Sparkles
  • Sheldon
  • Pierre
  • Leon
  • Kaz
  • Hamlet
  • Fritz
  • Bucky
  • Guac
  • Gigi
  • Peep
  • Bamboo
  • Hopper
Jellyroo Holiday Squishy Plush PBJ ⛄️ - Toys & Games
Jellyroo Holiday Squishy Plush PBJ ⛄️ - Toys & Games
13% off

Jellyroo Holiday Squishy Plush PBJ ⛄️

$14.99 $12.99 Sale

4 styles, 4 styles
  • +1 more
  • Rudy the Reindeer
  • Powder the Snowman
  • Tinsel the Elf
  • Santa
I’m Fine Everything’s Dumpster Fire | Punchkins - Plush
I’m Fine Everything’s Dumpster Fire | Punchkins - Bag Clip

🔥 I'm Fine Everything's Fine Dumpster Fire | Punchkins

from $11.99

2 styles, 2 styles
  • Plushie
  • Bag Clip
  • Plushie
  • Bag Clip
Squishville Mystery Mini Squishmallow Plush
Squishville Mystery Mini Squishmallow Plush
33% off

Squishville Mystery Mini Squishmallow Plush 🩷

$14.99 $9.99 Sale

I Baked You Some Shut The Fucupcakes | Punchkins - Gifts
I Baked You Some Shut The Fucupcakes | Punchkins - Gifts

🧁 I Baked You Some Shut The Fucupcakes | Punchkins

$24.99

Care Bear Beanies - Stuffed Animals
Care Bear Beanies - Stuffed Animals
25% off

Care Bear Beanies

from $14.99 Sale

10 styles, 10 styles
  • Grumpy Bear
  • Cheer Bear
  • Share Bear
  • +7 more
  • Grumpy Bear
  • Cheer Bear
  • Share Bear
  • Funshine Bear
  • Good Luck Bear
  • Tenderheart Bear
  • Love-A-Lot Bear
  • Togetherness Bear
  • Dare to Care Bear
  • I Care Bear
Spring Plush Mallows 🐣 - Bunny
Spring Plush Mallows 🐣 - Chick

Spring Plush Mallows 🐣

$4.99

PBJ’s Bravocado Plush Jellies
PBJ’s Bravocado Plush Jellies
33% off

PBJ's Bravocado Plush Jellies

$14.99 $9.99 Sale

Flick The Pukwudgie Plushie 🍄
Flick The Pukwudgie Plushie 🍄
29% off

Flick The Pukwudgie Plushie 🍄

from $9.99 Sale

2 styles, 2 styles
  • Flick
  • Palm Pal
*I’m So Over It | Punchkins - Gifts
*I’m So Over It | Punchkins - Gifts

*I'm So Over It | Punchkins

$24.99

Stoner Chick Plush | Punchkins
Stoner Chick Plush | Punchkins

🌿 Stoner Chick Plush | Punchkins

$24.99

Gribble the Goblin
Gribble the Goblin
17% off

Gribble the Goblin 🩵

$29.99 $24.99 Sale

1 style, 1 style
  • Gribble
  • Gribble
Spill the Tea Plush Teapot | Punchkins
Spill the Tea Plush Teapot | Punchkins

Spill the Tea Plush Teapot | Punchkins

$24.99

Big Foot Plush | Aurora 💜
Big Foot Plush | Aurora 💜

Big Foot Plush | Aurora 💜

from $29.99

2 sizes, 2 sizes
  • 12.5 Inches
  • 16.5 Inches
Grow A Pear | Punchkins - Plush
Grow A Pear | Punchkins - Plush

Grow A Pear | Punchkins

$24.99

Donut Bite Me | Punchkins - Donut- - Gifts
Donut Bite Me | Punchkins - Donut- - Gifts

🍩 Donut Bite Me | Punchkins

$24.99

Life Is Better With Sprinkles Punchkins - Plush
Life Is Better With Sprinkles Punchkins - Plush

🧁 Life Is Better With Sprinkles | Punchkins

$24.99

YooHoo Rainbow Pammee
YooHoo Rainbow Pammee
23% off

YooHoo Rainbow Pammee

$12.99 $9.99 Sale

🖤 My Little Wicked Friends | Glinda & Elphaba Wicked™ Plush Dolls
20% off

🖤 My Little Wicked Friends | Glinda & Elphaba Wicked™ Plush Dolls

$24.99 $19.99 Sale

2 styles, 2 styles
  • Glinda
  • Elphaba
Hot Mess Smore’S Punchkins - Plush
Hot Mess Smore’S Punchkins - Plush

Hot Mess Smore's Punchkins

$24.99

You Complete Me Donut Punchkins - Plush
You Complete Me Donut Punchkins - Plush

🍩 You Complete Me Donut | Punchkins

5.0 (1)

$24.99

Can’t We All Just Get A Bong? | Punchkins - Gifts
Can’t We All Just Get A Bong? | Punchkins - Gifts

💨 Can't We All Just Get A Bong? | Punchkins

$24.99

Don’t Hate Me Because I’M A Little Cooler | Punchkins
Don’t Hate Me Because I’M A Little Cooler | Punchkins

🧊 Don't Hate Me Because I'm A Little Cooler | Punchkins

$24.99

Matilda the Witch Doll 🧙🏼
Matilda the Witch Doll 🧙🏼
17% off

Matilda the Witch Doll 🧙🏼

$34.99 $28.99 Sale

*Dreamy Eyes Marley Sloth
*Dreamy Eyes Marley Sloth
40% off

*Dreamy Eyes Marley Sloth

$24.99 $14.99 Sale

Byron the Brachiosaurus 🦕
Byron the Brachiosaurus 🦕
28% off

Byron the Brachiosaurus 🦕

$24.99 $17.99 Sale

Tossimals - Orange Cat
Tossimals
20% off

Tossimals

$9.99 $7.99 Sale

9 styles, 9 styles
  • Gray Cat
  • Horse
  • Orange Cat
  • +6 more
  • Gray Cat
  • Horse
  • Orange Cat
  • Cow
  • Tan Dog
  • Duck
  • Cocoa Dog
  • Pig
  • Frog
Palm Pals Luna Bat
Palm Pals Luna Bat
33% off

Palm Pals Luna Bat

$14.99 $9.99 Sale

Welcome to the Shitshow Pillow| Punchkins - Plush
Welcome to the Shitshow Pillow| Punchkins - Plush
18% off

Welcome to the Shitshow Pillow| Punchkins

$39.99 $32.99 Sale

I’M Complicated Puzzle Cube Punchkins - Plush
I’M Complicated Puzzle Cube Punchkins - Plush

I'M Complicated Puzzle Cube Punchkins

$24.99

You’re So Cool Plush Ice Cream Cone | Punchkins
You’re So Cool Plush Ice Cream Cone | Punchkins

You're So Cool Plush Ice Cream Cone | Punchkins

$24.99

Rv There Yet Plush Camper | Punchkins
Rv There Yet Plush Camper | Punchkins

Rv There Yet Plush Camper | Punchkins

$24.99

I Love You S’More! Punchkins - Plush
I Love You S’More! Punchkins - Plush

I Love You S'More! Punchkins

$24.99

They See Me Rollin Cinnamon Sweet Roll Punchkins - Plush
They See Me Rollin Cinnamon Sweet Roll Punchkins - Plush

They See Me Rollin Cinnamon Sweet Roll Punchkins

$24.99

Rock Out With Your Guac | Punchkins - Gifts
Rock Out With Your Guac | Punchkins - Gifts

Rock Out With Your Guac Out | Punchkins

$24.99

I Like It Dirty Martini | Punchkins - Gifts
I Like It Dirty Martini | Punchkins - Gifts

I Like It Dirty Martini | Punchkins

$24.99

Sippin’ Wine and Shopping Prime Punchkin - Plush
Sippin’ Wine and Shopping Prime Punchkin - Plush

Sippin' Wine and Shopping Prime Punchkin

$24.99

😈 You’re My Soulmate Devil Goat | Punchkins

😈 You’re My Soulmate Devil Goat | Punchkins

$24.99

*Tasty Peach Neon Lollipop Nomwhal
*Tasty Peach Neon Lollipop Nomwhal
25% off

*Tasty Peach Neon Lollipop Nomwhal

$19.99 $14.99 Sale