💜 PAY OVER TIME WITH SEZZLE 💜

FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $149

FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $149. NOT VALID DURING SALES OR WITH OTHER DISCOUNTS

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Freshly Brewed Magick

New Arrivals

Plushies

130 Results

Clear filters
Jellyroo Plush Animals Squish Tummy
Jellyroo Plush Animals Squish Tummy
24% off

OG Jellyroos ™ Funny Tummies | Jellyroos ™

$18.89 $14.30 Sale

15 styles
  • Tutu
  • Huckleberry
  • Sparkles
  • Sheldon
  • Pierre
  • Leon
  • Kaz
  • Hamlet
  • Fritz
  • Bucky
  • Guac
  • Gigi
  • Peep
  • Bamboo
  • Sophia Lor-Hen
PBJ’s Plush Ball Jellies 💜 - Pugsy Malone - Stuffed Animals
PBJ’s Plush Ball Jellies 💜 - Stuffed Animals
35% off

PBJ's Plush Ball Jellies 💜

$15.74 $10.20 Sale

17 styles
  • Rainbow Unicorn
  • Fetch
  • Pugsy Malone
  • Cyclopz
  • Lily
  • Purrincess
  • Slowpoke
  • Triclopz
  • Spike
  • Mako
  • Delphine
  • Fish N. Chips
  • Fleecia
  • Chillie
  • Inky
  • Sizzley
  • Fowl Ball
🖤 My Little Wicked Friends | Glinda & Elphaba Wicked™ Plush Dolls
22% off

🖤 My Little Wicked Friends | Glinda & Elphaba Wicked™ Plush Dolls

$26.24 $20.40 Sale

2 styles
  • Glinda
  • Elphaba
Spring Plush Mallows 🐣 - Bunny
Spring Plush Mallows 🐣 - Chick

🐰✨ Bunny Bait Squishies ✨🐰

$5.10

Squishville Mystery Mini Squishmallow Plush
Squishville Mystery Mini Squishmallow Plush
35% off

Squishville Mystery Mini Squishmallow Plush 🩷

$15.74 $10.20 Sale

Holiday Squishy Bellies | Jellyroos ™ ⛄️
16% off

Holiday Squishy Bellies | Jellyroos ™ ⛄️

$15.74 $13.25 Sale

4 styles
  • Rudy the Reindeer
  • Powder the Snowman
  • Tinsel the Elf
  • Santa
Dinoroos | Jellyroos ™ 🦖✨
27% off

Dinoroos | Jellyroos ™ 🦖✨

$20.99 $15.30 Sale

4 styles
  • Pterri
  • Spike
  • Rexie
  • Chomp
I’m Fine Everything’s Dumpster Fire | Punchkins - Plush
I’m Fine Everything’s Dumpster Fire | Punchkins - Bag Clip

🔥 I'm Fine Everything's Fine Dumpster Fire | Punchkins

from $12.25

2 styles
  • Plushie
  • Bag Clip
Jelly Heads | Jellyroos ™ 💖✨
27% off

Jelly Heads | Jellyroos ™ 💖✨

$20.99 $15.30 Sale

6 styles
  • Unicorn
  • Black Cat
  • Axolotl
  • Narwhale
  • Duck
  • Dog
Care Bear Beanies - Stuffed Animals
Care Bear Beanies - Stuffed Animals
27% off

Care Bear Beanies

from $15.30 Sale

10 styles
  • Grumpy Bear
  • Cheer Bear
  • Share Bear
  • Funshine Bear
  • Good Luck Bear
  • Tenderheart Bear
  • Love-A-Lot Bear
  • Togetherness Bear
  • Dare to Care Bear
  • I Care Bear
I Baked You Some Shut The Fucupcakes | Punchkins - Gifts
I Baked You Some Shut The Fucupcakes | Punchkins - Gifts

🧁 I Baked You Some Shut The Fucupcakes | Punchkins

$25.50

PBJ’s Bravocado Plush Jellies
PBJ’s Bravocado Plush Jellies
Sold out

PBJ's Bravocado Plush Jellies

$15.74 $10.20 Sale

Stoner Chick Plush | Punchkins
Stoner Chick Plush | Punchkins
Sold out

🌿 Stoner Chick Plush | Punchkins

$25.50

Flick The Pukwudgie Plushie 🍄
Flick The Pukwudgie Plushie 🍄
31% off

Flick The Pukwudgie Plushie 🍄

from $10.20 Sale

2 styles
  • Flick
  • Palm Pal
Gribble the Goblin
Gribble the Goblin
Sold out

Gribble the Goblin 🩵

$31.49 $25.50 Sale

1 style
  • Gribble
Emotional Support Dumpster Fire 🔥🗑️

Emotional Support Dumpster Fire 🔥🗑️

$13.99

*I’m So Over It | Punchkins - Gifts
*I’m So Over It | Punchkins - Gifts

*I'm So Over It | Punchkins

$25.50

Jaffy the Fringe Footed Giraffe Toy - Toys & Games
Jaffy the Fringe Footed Giraffe Toy - Toys & Games
Sold out

Jaffy the Fringe Footed Giraffe Toy

$26.24 $15.30 Sale

Spill the Tea Plush Teapot | Punchkins
Spill the Tea Plush Teapot | Punchkins
Sold out

Spill the Tea Plush Teapot | Punchkins

$25.50

Light Up Alien Nebula
Light Up Alien Nebula
17% off

Light Up Alien Nebula

$20.99 $17.35 Sale

Tossimals - Orange Cat
Tossimals
22% off

Tossimals

$10.49 $8.15 Sale

9 styles
  • Gray Cat
  • Horse
  • Orange Cat
  • Cow
  • Tan Dog
  • Duck
  • Cocoa Dog
  • Pig
  • Frog
Big Foot Plush | Aurora 💜
Big Foot Plush | Aurora 💜

Big Foot Plush | Aurora 💜

from $30.60

2 sizes
  • 12.5 Inches
  • 16.5 Inches
Welcome to the Shitshow Pillow| Punchkins - Plush
Welcome to the Shitshow Pillow| Punchkins - Plush
Sold out

Welcome to the Shitshow Pillow| Punchkins

$41.99 $33.65 Sale

Life Is Better With Sprinkles Punchkins - Plush
Life Is Better With Sprinkles Punchkins - Plush

🧁 Life Is Better With Sprinkles | Punchkins

$25.50

*Dreamy Eyes Marley Sloth
*Dreamy Eyes Marley Sloth
42% off

*Dreamy Eyes Marley Sloth

$26.24 $15.30 Sale

Grey Tabby
Grey Tabby
27% off

Grey Tabby

$20.99 $15.30 Sale

Intergalactic Friend Bag Clip 👽 - Ralph Red Tie Dyed
Intergalactic Friend Bag Clip 👽 - Hank Green Tie Dyed
32% off

Intergalactic Friend Bag Clip 👽

$10.49 $7.15 Sale

2 styles
  • Ralph Red Tie Dyed
  • Hank Green Tie Dyed
Kibbles Kittens Plush Kitten
Kibbles Kittens Plush Kitten
14% off

Kibbles Kittens Plush Kitten

$17.84 $15.30 Sale

3 colors
Palm Pals Luna Bat
Palm Pals Luna Bat
35% off

Palm Pals Luna Bat

$15.74 $10.20 Sale

Palm Pals Tyranno Rex
Palm Pals Tyranno Rex
35% off

Palm Pals Tyranno Rex

$15.74 $10.20 Sale

Grow A Pear | Punchkins - Plush
Grow A Pear | Punchkins - Plush

Grow A Pear | Punchkins

$25.50

Donut Bite Me | Punchkins - Donut- - Gifts
Donut Bite Me | Punchkins - Donut- - Gifts

🍩 Donut Bite Me | Punchkins

$25.50

Precious Moments Dusty Donkey
Precious Moments Dusty Donkey
Sold out

Precious Moments Dusty Donkey

$28.34 $22.45 Sale

*Spriggie Unicorn Stella
*Spriggie Unicorn Stella
24% off

*Spriggie Unicorn Stella

$26.24 $19.99 Sale

Highland Cow Plushie | Jomanda Plush
Highland Cow Plushie | Jomanda Plush - Large
Up to 27% off

Highland Cow Plushie | Jomanda Plush

from $15.30 Sale

2 sizes
  • Mini
  • Large
Bedtime Monster Plush Book Set | Inklings 😴
17% off

Bedtime Monster Plush Book Set | Inklings 😴

$36.74 $30.60 Sale

2 styles
  • Gus
  • Wobbly
YooHoo Rainbow Pammee
YooHoo Rainbow Pammee
25% off

YooHoo Rainbow Pammee

$13.64 $10.20 Sale

OMG Snuggle Me Scented Bedtime Buddy 💤
OMG Snuggle Me Scented Bedtime Buddy 💤
11% off

OMG Snuggle Me Scented Bedtime Buddy 💤

$26.24 $23.45 Sale

I’M Complicated Puzzle Cube Punchkins - Plush
I’M Complicated Puzzle Cube Punchkins - Plush

I'M Complicated Puzzle Cube Punchkins

$25.50

Hot Mess Smore’S Punchkins - Plush
Hot Mess Smore’S Punchkins - Plush

Hot Mess Smore's Punchkins

$25.50