💜 PAY OVER TIME WITH SEZZLE 💜

FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $149

FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $149. NOT VALID DURING SALES OR WITH OTHER DISCOUNTS

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Freshly Brewed Magick

New Arrivals

Plushies

130 Results

Clear filters
I Love You S’More! Punchkins - Plush
I Love You S’More! Punchkins - Plush
Sold out

I Love You S'More! Punchkins

$25.50

💉 Nurses Call The Shots | Punchkins
Sold out

💉 Nurses Call The Shots | Punchkins

$25.50

😈 You’re My Soulmate Devil Goat | Punchkins

😈 You’re My Soulmate Devil Goat | Punchkins

$25.50

It’s About To Go Down Plunger | Punchkins - Plush
It’s About To Go Down Plunger | Punchkins - Plush
Sold out

🚽 It's About To Go Down Plunger | Punchkins

$25.50

You Complete Me Donut Punchkins - Plush
You Complete Me Donut Punchkins - Plush

🍩 You Complete Me Donut | Punchkins

5.0 (1)

$25.50

Can’t We All Just Get A Bong? | Punchkins - Gifts
Can’t We All Just Get A Bong? | Punchkins - Gifts

💨 Can't We All Just Get A Bong? | Punchkins

$25.50

Don’t Hate Me Because I’M A Little Cooler | Punchkins
Don’t Hate Me Because I’M A Little Cooler | Punchkins

🧊 Don't Hate Me Because I'm A Little Cooler | Punchkins

$25.50

Matilda the Witch Doll 🧙🏼
Matilda the Witch Doll 🧙🏼
20% off

Matilda the Witch Doll 🧙🏼

$36.74 $29.55 Sale

Rainbow Highland Cow | Jomanda Plush - Mini
Rainbow Highland Cow | Jomanda Plush
Up to 27% off

Rainbow Highland Cow | Jomanda Plush

from $15.30 Sale

2 sizes
  • Mini
  • Medium
Precious Moments Sammy Sloth
Precious Moments Sammy Sloth
21% off

Precious Moments Sammy Sloth

$28.34 $22.45 Sale

*Spudster Doodle Dog
*Spudster Doodle Dog
34% off

*Spudster Doodle Dog

$26.24 $17.35 Sale

My Little Ballerina - Lily - Stuffed Animals
My Little Ballerina - Stuffed Animals
22% off

My Little Ballerina

$26.24 $20.40 Sale

3 styles
  • Evie
  • Lilia
  • Lily
Byron the Brachiosaurus 🦕
Byron the Brachiosaurus 🦕
30% off

Byron the Brachiosaurus 🦕

$26.24 $18.35 Sale

Digby Plush Toy & Novel Set - Toys Games
Digby Plush Toy & Novel Set - Toys Games
Sold out

Digby Plush Toy & Novel Set

$36.74 $29.55 Sale

Palm Pals Prickles Cactus
Palm Pals Prickles Cactus
35% off

Palm Pals Prickles Cactus

$15.74 $10.20 Sale

Palm Pals Pisces Shooting Star
Palm Pals Pisces Shooting Star
35% off

Palm Pals Pisces Shooting Star

$15.74 $10.20 Sale

Palm Pals Thunder Bronto
Palm Pals Thunder Bronto
35% off

Palm Pals Thunder Bronto

$15.74 $10.20 Sale

Nuts About You Punchkins
Nuts About You Punchkins
Sold out

Nuts About You Punchkins

$25.50

You’re So Cool Plush Ice Cream Cone | Punchkins
You’re So Cool Plush Ice Cream Cone | Punchkins

You're So Cool Plush Ice Cream Cone | Punchkins

$25.50

They See Me Rollin Cinnamon Sweet Roll Punchkins - Plush
They See Me Rollin Cinnamon Sweet Roll Punchkins - Plush

They See Me Rollin Cinnamon Sweet Roll Punchkins

$25.50

Rock Out With Your Guac | Punchkins - Gifts
Rock Out With Your Guac | Punchkins - Gifts

Rock Out With Your Guac Out | Punchkins

$25.50

I Like It Dirty Martini | Punchkins - Gifts
I Like It Dirty Martini | Punchkins - Gifts

I Like It Dirty Martini | Punchkins

$25.50

Sippin’ Wine and Shopping Prime Punchkin - Plush
Sippin’ Wine and Shopping Prime Punchkin - Plush

Sippin' Wine and Shopping Prime Punchkin

$25.50

🍄 Cute But Toxic Mushroom | Punchkins

🍄 Cute But Toxic Mushroom | Punchkins

$25.50

👻 I Don't Like You Planchette | Punchkins

👻 I Don't Like You Planchette | Punchkins

$25.50

🧙 Quit Your Witchin | Punchkins

🧙 Quit Your Witchin | Punchkins

$25.50

📖 I Like My Horrors Sinister & Disturbing Book Plush | Punchkins

📖 I Like My Horrors Sinister & Disturbing Book Plush | Punchkins

$25.50

⚰️ Cute But Dead Inside Coffin | Punchkins

⚰️ Cute But Dead Inside Coffin | Punchkins

$25.50

*Tasty Peach Neon Lollipop Nomwhal
*Tasty Peach Neon Lollipop Nomwhal
27% off

*Tasty Peach Neon Lollipop Nomwhal

$20.99 $15.30 Sale

*Tasty Peach Black Sesame Meowchi - Stuffed Animals
32% off

*Tasty Peach Black Sesame Meowchi

$20.99 $14.30 Sale

+ Tasty Peach Berry Sunset Meowchi - Stuffed Animals
+ Tasty Peach Berry Sunset Meowchi - Stuffed Animals
32% off

+Tasty Peach Berry Sunset Meowchi

$20.99 $14.30 Sale

Tasty Peach Pastel Lollipop Nomwhal - Stuffed Animals
Tasty Peach Pastel Lollipop Nomwhal - Stuffed Animals
27% off

Tasty Peach Pastel Lollipop Nomwhal

$20.99 $15.30 Sale

Wazu Monster
Wazu Monster
22% off

Wazu Monster

$26.24 $20.40 Sale

*Spudster Kira Koala
*Spudster Kira Koala
39% off

*Spudster Kira Koala

$28.34 $17.35 Sale

*Spudster Spark Sloth
*Spudster Spark Sloth
39% off

*Spudster Spark Sloth

$28.34 $17.35 Sale

Potato Chips Fleece Plush
Potato Chips Fleece Plush
14% off

Potato Chips Fleece Plush

$47.24 $40.75 Sale

Bitsy Rainbow Gem Gnome 🌈 - Teal
Bitsy Rainbow Gem Gnome 🌈
22% off

Bitsy Rainbow Gem Gnome 🌈

$26.24 $20.40 Sale

2 colors
  • Groovy Grape
  • Teal
*Trevor the Giant Tyrannosaurus Rex
19% off

*Trevor the Giant Tyrannosaurus Rex

$31.49 $25.50 Sale

Dreamy Eyes Barnam Bear
Dreamy Eyes Barnam Bear
22% off

Dreamy Eyes Barnam Bear

$26.24 $20.40 Sale

Fantasy Yeti

Fantasy Yeti

$30.60